At 21 and 23, my kids are securely Gen Z, and I will defend so much about them and their generation until I run out of breath. Their commitment to social justice, to inclusion, to combating toxic masculinity and rape culture, their embrace of democratic socialism are all proof that Gen Z is the best thing Gen X has done. All those participation trophies and filling buckets with kindness and zero tolerance for bullying created a wonderful group of young people who are more engaged politically and more compassionate than any cohort in history. I am incredibly proud of them.
That said, their "humor" is just unbearably stupid. And Gen Alpha is so much worse.
Back in MY day™️, there was a certain genre of SNL skit where the writers just repeated the same thing over and over and somehow we were supposed to laugh. It was a lot of why I stopped watching SNL. Part of the basis, I guess, was making fun of dumb people, which I don't find clever. Don't get me wrong; I'm a terrible person and I sometimes find the things dumb people do funny, but I would never want to then go further and actively mock them for it. It's too mean-spirited for even my black heart, and it's not funny.
Flash forward twenty years, and as Gen Z began to create their own content and memes, to use the modern terms for youth culture, Antonio especially would show me things he found hysterical and I literally did not understand why he was laughing. It wasn't just, "I think that's offensive" or "I personally don't think slapstick or pranks are entertaining," but just...how is it supposed to be funny? I seriously just did not get it. Is it ironic? Does it highlight an absurdity about the human condition? Is it a clever play on words? Is there something utterly unexpected going on? No?
Maybe the first version of the internet version of this bullshit that I remember was the "I can has cheezburger" cat meme. Like, ok. Cats want fast food, and they speak English but poorly. Ha ha? And it got worse from there. I remember staring blankly at an Instagram post that Antonio showed me and searching for any way in which it might have been entertaining, and I could come up with nothing—not even something to roll my eyes at.
When I discovered that the George Michael song "Careless Whisper," had become weirdly popular with Gen Z and I was a little flummoxed as to why THAT song. An older Gen Z, or maybe she's a millennial, explained it away as "it's a meme." What does that even mean? It's funny because...it gets sent around? It's not even like Rick Rolling, which is less about Rick Astley than the surprise of expecting one thing and getting a nineties one-hit wonder instead. That it's "Never Gonna Give You Up" hardly matters. At least I understand THAT.
This week after hearing in grown up media about these damn kids on my lawn and their 6-7, I ended up looking it up and it has NO MEANING. Some kids just repeat it, meaning...nothing. Is it just to annoy adults with senselessness? Is it "you don't get it cuz you're an Old"? Back in MY day™️, we had lots of "you don't get it because you're an Old," but it was "you don't get the combination of anger and ennui expressed in grunge," not "you don't get it...because there is nothing to get."
And being the over thinker that I am, and wanting to defend young people because us Olds have historically been shitty to young people, I want it to be something profound. I want it to be a critique of Late Stage Capitalism or a statement about the existentialist shallowness of modern corporate media or an example of cognitive semantics.
But in the end, yeah, I guess it's probably just not that deep, bro.